Cheba Hut’s Sticky Icky has carved out its own niche among toasted subs, delivering a playful spin on the classic peanut butter and jelly. This sandwich isn’t just nostalgic it’s reinvented for adults with a fun, bold twist that aligns with Cheba Hut’s cannabis-themed branding. Whether you’re craving comfort food or looking for an unexpected indulgence, the Sticky Icky manages to balance sweet, salty, and savory in a way that stands out on the menu.
What Is the Sticky Icky?
The Sticky Icky is essentially a peanut butter and jelly sub no surprise there but with added flair. Cheba Hut offers it on their signature toasted bread, slathered with creamy peanut butter and your choice of jelly (grape or strawberry), along with a drizzle of honey. In some locations, you can order it with a crisp slice of bacon for an extra savory kick.
Its name refers to an old-school slang term for potent cannabis, aligning with the brand’s fun, stoner-friendly vibe. But don’t let the theme fool you it’s a solid choice for anyone who loves good sandwiches, not just those chasing the munchies.
Signature Bread and Build
The foundation of the Sticky Icky is Cheba Hut’s artisanal bread, described by customers as crisp on the outside and tender inside.
Choosing your jelly is part of the fun. Grape jelly is the traditional favorite, while strawberry offers a brighter sweetness. The optional bacon adds a crunchy, salty contrast that plays nicely with the sticky sweetness of jam and honey.
Flavor Experience
The Sticky Icky delivers layers of taste: the nutty creaminess of peanut butter, followed by fruit-forward jelly, the gentle warmth of honey, and optionally, smoky, crunchy bacon. Toasting unifies these components into a comforting whole that’s both nostalgic and a bit unexpected.
User reviews highlight the bread and combo appeal. One TikTok reviewer described it as not a lot going on on the outside, but honestly, not that bad with the bread is actually really good.
Customization and Menu Context
Like many items at Cheba Hut, the Sticky Icky lives in a playful menu full of weed-themed names. It’s a standout in the Veggies section because it’s a non-meat sandwich that still satisfies big flavor expectations.
Cheba Hut encourages customization. You can tuck it inside garlic-herb bread, add bacon, jalapeños, or even pair it with a Kool-Aid on the side, as they cheekily note: You’re gonna want a Kool-Aid.
Who Will Love It?
The Sticky Icky appeals to several groups:
- Fans of PB&J with a grown-up twist
- Vegetarian customers looking for indulgent comfort
- Adventurous eaters drawn to quirky, themed restaurants
- Sandwich lovers who appreciate quality bread and playful combos
Even skeptics concede it hits the mark: Better than Jimmy John’s Better than Subway according to one enthusiastic TikToker.
Criticisms and Considerations
That said, it may not be for everyone. Some reviews note it lacks meat for hearty eaters.
How to Order It Right
If you’re trying the Sticky Icky for the first time, here are some tips:
- Choose toasted bread (white, whole wheat, or garlic-herb) for best texture
- Pick your jelly grape for nostalgia, strawberry for brightness
- Add bacon if you want a sweet-salty crunch
- Try it with Kool-Aid or fountain drink for a classic Cheba Hut combo
These tweaks help ensure you get a satisfying takeaway from the sandwich.
Sticky Icky in the Wider Menu
Cheba Hut is known for its creative sub lineup names like White Widow, Kali Mist, and G-13 reflect cannabis strains and the chain’s culture-friendly ethos.
Its position next to veggie subs highlights Cheba Hut’s intention to cater beyond the classic stoner crowd, offering accessibility and flavors that appeal across consumer types.
Atmosphere and Experience
Many Cheba Hut locations feature a laid-back vibe with bar seating, event nights, and stoner-chic décor. The atmosphere is casual and social, making it easy to jump in for a solo bite or a group meet-up.
Inside, the Sandwich environment is friendly and relaxed, often with local beers or community events exactly the kind of setting where someone might reach for a Sticky Icky on a fun night out.
Final Verdict
The Sticky Icky is a creatively resurrected PB&J, anchored by quality toasted bread and elevated with honey, optional bacon, and custom choices. It stands out in Cheba Hut’s sandwich lineup by offering a vegetarian-friendly, comforting option that pairs nostalgia with novelty. Fans appreciate its simplicity and execution, especially when enhanced with garlic bread or a drink.
While it might not satisfy the hungriest meat-lovers on its own, the Sticky Icky fills a niche for sweet-salty comfort and clearly resonates with customers seeking flavorful, unconventional subs. For those seeking a taste of nostalgia with a twist or a dependable vegetarian pick this sticky, sweet sub is worth checking out on your next visit to Cheba Hut.
: